← Back to context

Comment by Arnavion

1 year ago

Right. I've never used PyPI, but TFA makes it sound like the existing support for signing is "We allow the uploader to upload a signature, and the downloader can look up the key indicated in the signature to do the verification." Is that correct? If so, then yes there is a key ID involved but no email address, so a generic downloader would have no choice but to look it up from a key server.

4 comments

Arnavion

Reply
woodruffw  1 year ago

That's correct!

PyPI's support for PGP is very old -- it's hard to get an exact date, but I think it's been around since the very earliest versions of the index (well before it was a storing index like it is now). If I had to guess (speculate wildly), my guess would be that the original implementation was done with a healthy SKS network and strong set in mind -- without those things, PGP's already weak identity primitives are more or less nonexistent with just signatures.