← Back to context

Comment by givemeethekeys

3 months ago

I'd give Windows some credit - it is actually quite good and stable these days.

No denying that windows these days isn’t stable. Indeed it is. My biggest issue is all the third party crap I never asked for gets installed with it. Not to mention all the Microsoft services that I don’t want to use, but still manage to be there. Like OneDrive. Sure one can uninstall it. But then see the mess it leaves with the way files are saved in the documents directory.

Even when setting up a Windows 11 VM , I usually have to spend an hour just removing stuff, disabling things and multiple reboots just to trim things down.

  • > I usually have to spend an hour just removing stuff, disabling things and multiple reboots just to trim things down.

    All of that is automated now. https://atlasos.net

    • yeah, I've used plenty of community made tools to de-bloat windows. But that's not the point. We shouldn't have to do that. Especially when its a paid windows license, I shouldn't have to spend time dealing with Microsoft's effort at further squeezing out more revenue from their OS platform.

      1 reply →

  • If you set your language to 'English (World)' during the install, none of the crapware is installed.

    Or at least it wasn't last year when I installed W11 (I still occasionally need Affinity Photo and Capture One). Microsoft might have realised they're missing out on a few pennies and plugged the gap.

Good is relative. Windows 2000 never reset your preferences on an update of the OS.

  • Windows 2000 was the pinnacle of Windows. Rock solid, and that was before they broke the search function (when it actually still actually searched in files rather than an incomplete index - thankfully, grepWin can be installed) or when they dumbed down the Control Panel.

    • > when it actually still actually searched in files rather than an incomplete index

      I don't even care about in files. I just want a file named foo.txt to appear when I search for "foo" on the directory containing it.

      Windows 10 is completely unable to run that search.

      2 replies →

WSL still doesn't have the proper UNIX like experience of macOS.

And there is no decent equivalent to homebrew.

  • Imo, it's much more of a proper Linux experience than MacOS. e.g. all the filesystems stuff is there like /proc, you don't have to deal with BSD/Linux differences, zsh/bash compat issues etc.

    macOS Unix compatibility is an oversold feature, and it's unlikely for anything made for Linux to work on it unless it's specifically ported.

    That being sad, a lot of the dev community own macs, so this support usually exists.

  • I mean with Hyper-V why even WSL and just run VMs of whatever other OS'es you want? Tinkering with the OS these days is just so much different than it was in the past. Trying to dual boot Win/Linux back in the day was a interesting challenge that might leave your disk corrupt, now it's a question of why do that at all? Hacking smaller platforms like the pi that are cheap seems to get more attention than PCs these days.

    • WSL gives you much better integration with the rest of the OS. These days it even covers GUI Linux apps.

Yep, I don’t think I’ve had windows crash in atleast 2-3 years and I do a lot of strange, processor heavy things.