That an official government document explicitly mentioning that school staff is allowed to search a device without law enforcement (either being present, or authorized by warrant) is problematic in and of itself.
You can decline this at any age. What can they do? Well turns out at that point they can only threaten to or apply violence or confiscate it until you hand over the details, none of which are "reasonable in all circumstances" as quoted in the legislation.
So the correct answer is to tell your kids to tell them to get fucked and call you. At that point, remind them that the device is your property, decline their request and they can only threaten you, which is 100% illegal.
I am more worried about the teachers from experience than the other students. Some of them I have encountered over the last 15 years of having three kids at school have been right nasty pieces of work and should not be in a position to have power over a minor.
I agree that teachers should be able to enforce discipline in schools.
With that said, I've got no idea what schools should do about things like sexting.
If I was a teacher and I confiscated a phone which might have illegal photos of underage students on it, I wouldn't want to turn a blind eye to that. But I also sure as hell wouldn't want to search it myself. I'd want that done by someone of unimpeachable character.
That an official government document explicitly mentioning that school staff is allowed to search a device without law enforcement (either being present, or authorized by warrant) is problematic in and of itself.
You can decline this at any age. What can they do? Well turns out at that point they can only threaten to or apply violence or confiscate it until you hand over the details, none of which are "reasonable in all circumstances" as quoted in the legislation.
So the correct answer is to tell your kids to tell them to get fucked and call you. At that point, remind them that the device is your property, decline their request and they can only threaten you, which is 100% illegal.
I am more worried about the teachers from experience than the other students. Some of them I have encountered over the last 15 years of having three kids at school have been right nasty pieces of work and should not be in a position to have power over a minor.
I disagree. You don't need a warrant to search your child's phone as a parent.
Teachers have many of the same powers over children that their parents do. Power to detain, to punish, and yes to search.
If you're not happy with that as a parent then you can home educate them instead.
I disagree. Teachers don't have those powers unless parents explicitly opt in.
Also, your argument is pretty much "if you don't like it just leave". Which is one of the worst arguments for pretty much anything.
but why? if im a teacher getting wind of cyberbullying, or a photo being shared, what should i do? call the police every time?
im telling you, the police will not like that policy any more than the students.
you're in a school. you don't have the right to do whatever you please.
I agree that teachers should be able to enforce discipline in schools.
With that said, I've got no idea what schools should do about things like sexting.
If I was a teacher and I confiscated a phone which might have illegal photos of underage students on it, I wouldn't want to turn a blind eye to that. But I also sure as hell wouldn't want to search it myself. I'd want that done by someone of unimpeachable character.
2 replies →