← Back to context

Comment by im3w1l

16 days ago

I don't think this is exactly correct. Undefined behavior means a very specific thing - that the program could do literally anything. But I think that's not quite the situation in this case. Rather, I would suspect that these specified-register variables are only guaranteed to be effective with extended asm constraints.

For basic asm I would assume then that the register contents cannot be relied on to contain the value of the variable, but as long as you don't rely on it, then you are in the clear.

Then again it's hard to be sure about these matters with C.

> For basic asm I would assume then that the register contents cannot be relied on to contain the value of the variable, but as long as you don't rely on it, then you are in the clear.

That's the crux. The example invokes 'syscall', which obviously relies on specific register content, from basic asm.