Comment by uecker

21 hours ago

Function overloading is a feature that makes code less self-documenting without providing any meaningful value. Operator overloading is more interesting, because you can build you domain language with nice syntax. But I also tend to think that this is not really worth it.

2 comments

uecker

listeria 3 hours ago

Function overloading enables the building of powerful idioms like swap, operator== and this [1] proposal for composable hashing to name a few. And when combined with templates (and ADL to provide some encapsulation with namespaces) you can build some interesting abstractions akin to the io module in go, like this implementation of io.ReadFull():

    template<typename R>
    constexpr ssize_t
    io::ReadFull(R reader, char *buf, size_t len)
    {
      ssize_t recvd = 0, ret;

      do {
        ret = read(reader, &buf[recvd], len - recvd);
        if (ret > 0)
          recvd += ret;
        else
          break;
      } while (recvd < len);

      return recvd;
    }

---

1: https://open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2014/n3980.h...

adamrezich 19 hours ago

In C++ where you have methods? Sure. It would be nice to have in C, though. But, alas, ABI compatibility.