← Back to context

Comment by GoblinSlayer

7 hours ago

Presumably missing session is an alternative scenario and thus should be reported as an error, then you match and handle this error. Your design complicates the common scenario: in case of valid session you need double unwrap, cf File::open that could return Result<Option<File>> if file is not found.

>> Presumably missing session is an alternative scenario and thus should be reported as an error

But in this case, a query using an invalid session ID is not an error. It is asking for details about something that does not exist.

>> cf File::open that could return Result<Option<File>> if file is not found.

This type of query is not like File::open which gets a handle to a resource. Trying to get a handle to a resource that does not exist is an error.

This type of query is read-only and does not allocate any resources or prepare to do anything with the session.

It simplifies the control flow because it distinguishes between errors in completing a query versus the presence or absence of items returned from the query.