Comment by accelbred
19 hours ago
C++ can seamlessly include C89 headers.
The C library headers for libraries I write often include C11/C99 stuff that is invalid in C++.
Even when they are in C89, they are often incorrect to include without the include being in an `extern "C"`.
Extern "C" around the prototypes is mandatory, otherwise your linker will search for C++ symbols, which cannot be found in the C libraries you pass it.
Clang supports C11 - 23 in C++, as well as some future C features like fixed-point integers. The main pain points with Clang are just the fundamental differences like void* and char, which don't typically matter much at an interoperability layer.
There's a lot of subtle differences between 'proper' C and the C subset of C++, since C++ uses C++ semantics everywhere, even for its C subset.
Many C++ coders are oblivious to those differences (myself included before I switched from 'mainly C++' to 'mainly C') because they think that the C subset of C++ is compatible with 'proper' C, but any C code that compiles both in a C++ and C compiler is actually also a (heavily outdated) subset of the C language (so for a C coder it takes extra effort to write C++ compatible C code, and it's not great because it's a throwback to the mid-90s, C++ compatible C is potentially less safe and harder to maintain).
For instance in C++ it's illegal to take the address of an 'adhoc-constructed' function argument, like:
(godbolt: https://www.godbolt.org/z/r7r5rPc6K)
Interestingly, Objective-C leaves its C subset alone, so it is always automatically compatible with the latest C features without requiring a new 'ObjC standard'.
Because Objective-C initial proposal is that everything that isn't touched by Smalltalk like code, clearly in brackets or @annotarions, is plain C.
The pre-processor original compiler, before the GCC fork, would leave everything else alone, blindly copying into the generated C file.
Yeah plenty of headers first have `#ifdef __cplusplus` and then they add `extern "C"`. And of course even then they have to avoid doing things unacceptable in C++ such as using "new" as the name of a variable.
It takes a little bit of an effort to make a header work on C and C++. A lot less effort than making a single Python file work with Python 2 and 3.
The '#ifdef __cplusplus extern "C" { }' thing only removes C++ name mangling from exported symbols, it doesn't switch the C++ language into "C mode" (unfortunately).